About a year or so ago my now 3 year old Newf was diagnosed with Hip Dysplasia. He has since been on Glucosamine, Chondroitin and MSM, vitamin C, Salmon and Fish oil. Ben's hip has gotten progressively worse and he has been getting regular check ups. He has undergone cortisone shots which were effective, but short lived. Anyways we are to the point now of having to look at something more permanent. Our vet is recommending Femoral Head and Neck Excision. He feels that since Ben is only 3 we need more than just a "bandaid" (ie medication) fix for him. He feels he would be a great candidate for the surgery. I really need some advice. I am having such a hard time being able to accept this. I know we need to do something because Ben is in alot of pain. Just the other day he and I were walking across the yard, it was really quiet out and I could hear his hip ball and socket literally knocking together, it was horrible. Poor Guy. I do think this is probably the right thing to do, but I am having such a hard time with this. It makes me sick the thought of taking my guy to the vet and leaving him there knowing that he is going to be cut into and part of his hip bone is going to be removed. Oh my God, what do I do??? I am hoping there is someone out there who has been through this that can help. If there is please come forward. It's so hard to make a decision for someone who is unable to speak. My vet has done this surgery on many other large breed dogs, he did it on a 11 month old Newfy who lived till he was 9 and enjoyed a quality life. Any advice would be appreciated. Thank you.