Heritability of cruciate rupture in Newfies

Kitty

New member
Anyone else heard about this paper?

It asserts that rupture of the cranial cruciate ligament in Newfies may be a recessive trait. The hope is to identify a genetic marker that could be used by breeders to decrease the incidence of CCL rupture in Newfs.

Here's the abstract:

Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association
January 1, 2006, Vol. 228, No. 1, Pages 61-64
doi:10.2460/javma.228.1.61


Inheritance of rupture of the cranial cruciate ligament in Newfoundlands

Vicki L. Wilke DVM, DACVS Michael G. Conzemius DVM, PhD, DACVS Brian P. Kinghorn PhD Paula E. Macrossan PhD Weiguo Cai ​‌Max F. Rothschild PhD
Department of Animal Sciences, Center for Integrated Animal Genomics, Iowa State University, Ames, IA 50011-1250 (Wilke, Cai, Rothschild); Department of Veterinary Clinical Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine, Iowa State University, Ames, IA 50011-1250 (Wilke, Conzemius); Department of Animal Sciences, University of New England, Armidale, NSW 2351, Australia (Kinghorn, Macrossan)

Correspondence to: Address correspondence to Dr. Wilke.
Supported by the American Kennel Club Canine Health Foundation; Orthopedic Research Laboratory, College of Veterinary Medicine, Iowa State University; Department of Animal Science, Iowa State University; Special Research Initiation Grant, Iowa Agriculture and Home Economics Experiment Station; and Hatch and State of Iowa funds.

Presented at the 31st Veterinary Orthopedic Society Annual Conference, Big Sky, Mont, February 2004, and at the 14th American College of Veterinary Surgeons Symposium, Denver, October 2004.

The authors thank Drs. John Garbe and Yang Da for assistance with the pedigree.

Objective—To determine prevalence, level of inbreeding, heritability, and mode of inheritance for rupture of the cranial cruciate ligament (RCCL) in Newfoundlands.

Design—Retrospective and recruitment study.

Animals—574 client-owned Newfoundlands.

Procedure—Medical records from January 1, 1996, to December 31, 2002, were evaluated for prevalence of RCCL. A pedigree was constructed by use of recruited Newfoundlands with RCCL status based on results of veterinary examination; level of inbreeding, heritability, and mode of inheritance were calculated.

Results—Hospital prevalence for RCCL was 22%; dogs in the pedigree from the recruitment study had a mean level of inbreeding of 1.19 × 104, heritability of 0.27, and a possible recessive mode of inheritance with 51% penetrance for RCCL.

Conclusions and Clinical Relevance—Identification of a genetic basis for RCCL in Newfoundlands provided evidence that investigators can now focus on developing methods to identify carriers to reduce the prevalence of RCCL.

(My emphasis with the bold type)
 

sarnewfie

New member
i am very interested in the results, if they do find a marker i hope they can.
i have yet to have this problem, but, never say never, it could happen to anyone of my newfs at anytime.
it does in people to.
i sent in samples for them but never got word about anything, it is neat to be able to read any progress they might be making.
thanx for sharing this.
 

Sailorgirl

New member
It would be good if they could pinpoint this to genetics. In humans there is a school of thought that ACL injuries are related to how the bones in the leg line up (hence why female athletes are more prone to ACL tears than male athletes --because their hips tend to be wider and the angle in the bones is much greater), which I supposed is hereditary. If it's a similar thing in dogs it would be much more difficult to pinpoint than if there is an actual gene found. There are also specific programs for young athletes that work on building muscles to help prevent such injuries. Wouldn't it be nice if someone could devise a specific exercise regimen for dogs that would do the same thing?
 

janices

New member
I looked at the paper and it's interesting. I'm wondering also if it's an inherited predisposition and there are things can do to prevent acl from happening like building muscles to prevent such injuries. I haven't experienced an acl injury either yet. I've been in seminars where gone through certain type of body structure predisposes dog to acl injuries. And am wondering by breeding changes in the original body structure type plus the high coi's see out there if haven't now predisposed newfs to acl injuries.

[ 01-27-2006, 12:04 PM: Message edited by: janices ]
 

fdoremieux

Inactive Member
I have unfortunately done a lot of reading in the past few days. One hypothesis I have found in TPLO related material (not sure where that was exactly, I will try and find the quote) is that the genetic trait would be linked to the actual slope of the tibia plateau... that if that angle was more than 25 or 30 degrees it could indicate an increased risk. I have not seen any indication that the ligament itself would be more brittle, for example. Has anyone? Interestingly, my breeder has only experienced a handfull of ACL issues in 30+ years in all the dogs of their breeding program, which might indicate that there is a shared characteristic - indication of genetics probably. But as I can personally testify to, that does not prevent freak accidents :(
 

Sound Bay Newfs

Active member
Yes, I too have read that it the angle that is the factor. If that is the case, then certain lines may be more prone to this injury.
 

wrknnwf

Active member
I have the draft of the full article which Dr. Wilke published in JAVMA if anyone wants to read it.

Actually, there are two articles. One on the inheritance of the disease and one on the economic impact of the disease in the US.

These are .pdf files.
 

janices

New member
From some of my structure seminar notes a breed with very few acl injuries is german shepherds (dogs with more angulation have very few acl injuries) while dogs with straight rears more prone to acl injuries. There are newfs with more angulation and others a straighter angulation. Angulation would relate to the slope of the tibia plateau. Which seems to imply to me also that certain lines would be more prone to injuries.
 

NinaA

New member
I don't know about certain lines, but I just left the ortho surgeon's office yesterday. We're scheduled for a TPLO on Friday. He says he's seeing Newfoundlands right and left. To prove his point, we walked out into the waiting room and there was a Newf. Our vet says he thinks that breeders are breeding out the bad hips and it's making the knees meet at the wrong angle or the shape of the bones are changing.

Nina
et al
 

sarnewfie

New member
and a litter out of that male can be disastrous depending on what it is crossed with, nothing is set in stone, and, i would like to see proof that bad hips are being bred out, i have not seen evidance of that, the only way it could is if whole litters are clearing, and, so far i have not seen that.
do you know for a fact that those four generations are "clean"? many people lie, and, of course, i have to also ask, did you see each and every pup out of those four generations?
just curious.
i am not convinced one bit, that just becouse something is supposedly clear, and this is not meant personally to you, that any female he is bred to will have a healthy litter.
 

ardeagold

New member
What SAR says is right. What about the effect of the dam's bloodline? What about the effect of the two bloodlines together?

It takes two to tango, and many problems that didn't pop up in one breeding, might in another.

So, if there is a pup with problems out of your breeding to the German dog...would that mean that YOUR dam has the problem? Or would it mean that together their genes just aren't the best combination?

Until there is a DNA test for every illness/disease/problem known to the breed...you'll never know for sure.

But, that's not to say that you shouldn't go the most sensible route. And based on what information you have...the German dog sounds like a good choice.
 

sarnewfie

New member
who knows what is right, no one does, what people have is belief in certain ways to do things, no one has found the miracle formula for breeding, and no one has come to agreement on breeding,when things are as polygenic in nature as joint disease and heart disease, same disease that affects us humans, than yes all you can do is stick up for what you believe in, due to experiences you have had.
i am happy with what i have done so far in my years of being in this breed. i am sure others are to, and, i prolly do things a bit different than some do.
 

saddust

New member
Originally posted by newfhaven:
Well I guess my feeling is ya gotta start somewhere. There are kennels out there that do breed religiously for health. Mary Price with Dryad was one.
You've got this wrong - Dryad was Kitty Drury and she transferred Dryad Kennels to Mary Dewey in 1973... Mary Dewey sadly died3 years ago... Joan Gunn has many of her dogs but her kennel is known as Blackwatch...

So I think you've got some of your facts confused...

There are two well known Mary Price's in the NCA but neither has ever owned Dryad or bred under that name...

Karen
 

DreamTime Newfs

New member
Well, I for one know many pups that were sired by Hawkeye(Ch. Toad Hall's Field of Dreams) that are perfectly healthy. I do not think it is a great idea to go ripping a dog on a public forum. I realize that the intent of your post was supposed to be educational in nature but I think it was inappropriate. That is just my opinion.
 
Top